The Adoptive Plane (Revisited)
A while back I brought up the Adoptive Plane that a buddy (who we will call Farmer Boy) and I came up with while driving back home from an CUB retreat. Neither one of us really like the triangle so we started discussing a way to better represent it.
The Triad
The three main groups of adoption are usually represented by a triangle however, this can misrepresent the reality of the members of adoption.

The triangle appears to:
- demonstrate an equal distance or separation between the three members.
- show an equal or harmonious connection between the adoptee and the adoptee’s two families.
- symbolize that the birth family and adoptive family are raising the child’s interest above their own.
- exhibit that the relationship or communication between the adoptee and their adoptive and birth family is equal and similar.
These are rarely true.
The Plane
The plane (a flat or level surface) shows the adoptee between the other two members.

This better represents the truth behind adoption and it’s members. It can also display the way many adoptees feel like the center of a tug-of-war between their loyalties to the adoptive family and their longing to know their heritage and and blood.
By adjusting the image, the plane can illustrate an adoptee’s emotions or state of mind, moving back and forth between the two families.

This plane illustrates an adoptee moving (searching?) towards their birth family. It is also important to note that the arrow only represents the status on that side of the plane. In this case, the adoptee and Adoptive family are not moving away nor moving closer.

This plane illustrates an adoptee moving towards their adoptive family. (Retreating to familiarity?) Again, this movement has no impact on the birth family side in this diagram.

This plane can illustrate an adoptee’s emotions being torn between their two families.

Here is another representation of an adoptee who is pulling away from his adoptive family and they from him as he moves toward his biological family.

I was asked once why we call it a plane instead of just the Adoptive line. The reason is that there can be multiple lines branching out in different directions.
The following plane represents me at the time of writing, an adoptee who is currently searching for his birth family. The relationship with the adoptive family is good and they are supportive of the adoptee searching which is representative of each dot having an arrow pointing toward each other.

As you can see, the birth father is a question mark since he is unknown. I am trying to move towards the birth mother, however she is moving away since she denied contact. An uncle was also notified I was looking but the angency won’t put us in contact. Note also, the connecting line between the adoptee and the adoptive family has grown shorter to represent the closeness and support.
Finally, this is my sister’s who is in the process of reuniting now.

She is close with our parents and they are in full support. She has recently recieved a letter from her mother who is interested in contact. She does not currently know who her father is.
The Goal
The goal is to join all three representative circles into one family. A melding, as it were, of the adoptees two families into one united family which still have characteristics of each family. I know this is probably pretty rare but not inconceivable.

Conclusion
While Farmer Boy and I understand this is not an exact method of measurement, we believe it is a much better visual of the true nature of adoption as well as the feelings of each member of the plane. It also allows for the including of other facets usually left of by the triangle such as spouses, aunts, uncles, siblings, etc.
So what do you think?

May 2nd, 2007 at 6:29 pm
I love it! It is similar to sociograms that I do for clients (I’m a therapist). I love how the dynamics show movement and are changeable. I hate that adoptees are often put intensionally/unintensionally?? on that plane that emotional-tug-of-war that ensues
May 3rd, 2007 at 5:22 am
I think it’s brilliant. I lead people to this analogy often and use it myself exclusively.
May 4th, 2007 at 3:39 pm
I think Mia may have sent me to your orig. post about this, and I in turn sent a link to a non-blogging friend. I’ve always disliked the adoption “triad” concept. Too simple.
The adoption plane makes more sense. I love it!
May 5th, 2007 at 1:14 pm
I think it makes alot more sense what you guys came up with, it feels much more honest and leaves room for variations, where as the other way seems so fixed and rigid.
MSP
May 8th, 2007 at 9:16 pm
Wraith, This is fantastic! I can see the last 10 years of my life in your illustrations. The goal is possible. I’m living it. In fact, my dad has gotten together with my first mom and her family even when I haven’t been there. I hope you can reach it too. Best wishes, Rebecca
May 12th, 2007 at 10:31 pm
I hope for the bee that we can all be a big blob of a family. I cannot parent her the way I want to, or the way she needs without her natural mom. I think the blob is possible, but it is hard work. It is much harder than my marriage, or blending our nutso families, but it is also worth it because we are playing with a tiny person who has no say in the whole thing.
July 4th, 2007 at 7:33 am
Wraith, thank you for the visualiztion of the plane. Several years ago my found daughter’s last letter to me said she felt “caught in the middle.” I couldn’t understand it. I had made no demands. I only hoped there was room in her life for love from both directions, her adoptive family and her birthfamily. But I also knew her adoptive family felt negatively about her having a relationship with us. I am no longer sure about sending a birthday or Christmas card. Is that putting more pressure on her and does she even want a card? How do you know with no contact?